The material of a shower curtain matters more than its pattern. Fabric looks soft and washes in the machine; plastic keeps water in the tub and wipes clean.
The two picks below, a cotton fabric curtain and a PEVA plastic liner, show the trade-off and also work together. Details come from their published listings.
For keeping water in, the Mrs Awesome PEVA liner is the pick; for looks, hang the Madison Park Arlo cotton curtain outside it.
📌 This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED ‘AS IS’ AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets (PEVA Plastic Liner)
Madison Park Arlo Cotton Waffle Shower Curtain (Fabric Curtain)
Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Buy Link |
|---|---|---|
| Madison Park Arlo Cotton Waffle Shower Curtain | Spa-style bathrooms | Check Price |
| Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets | Waterproof barrier | Check Price |
How We Chose These Fabric and Plastic Shower Curtains
One curtain was chosen for each material so the comparison stays on fabric versus plastic. Each was checked for material as listed, size, water handling, care and hardware. An earlier version of this page listed cotton quilting squares on the fabric side; they have been replaced with a finished fabric shower curtain.
Madison Park Arlo Cotton Waffle Shower Curtain (Fabric Curtain)
Quick take: Madison Park’s Arlo is a 100% cotton shower curtain in a heavy waffle weave, machine washable and OEKO-TEX certified, for a soft, hotel-style look.
The listing describes a 100% cotton, heavy waffle weave base fabric in a medium weight that drapes naturally. It measures the standard 72 by 72 inches, weighs about 2.15 pounds, and the listing title notes OEKO-TEX certification.
Care is machine washing, so the curtain can be laundered rather than replaced. The listing does not describe it as waterproof, so plan to hang it with an inner liner on the shower side, as is usual for cotton curtains.
Pros:
- Natural cotton: 100% cotton in a textured waffle weave.
- Machine washable: Launder instead of replacing.
- OEKO-TEX certified: Per the listing title.
Cons:
- Not listed as waterproof: Needs a liner inside the tub.
- Slower to dry: Cotton holds more water than plastic.
Who Should Buy This
Great match for: bathrooms where a soft, spa-like look matters, paired with a liner. Think twice if: you want a single curtain with no liner.
Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets (PEVA Plastic Liner)
Quick take: A lightweight clear PEVA liner that is PVC-free, with three magnets at the hem and 12 rustproof metal grommets.
Mrs Awesome lists PEVA, a PVC-free plastic that makes water bead on the surface and wipes clean with a damp cloth. The liner measures 72 by 72 inches and weighs about 0.62 pounds.
Three encased magnets at the bottom are meant to stick to cast iron tubs and stop the liner blowing in or clinging, and a reinforced top header holds 12 rustproof metal grommets. It can hang alone or inside a decorative fabric curtain.
Pros:
- Waterproof: Water beads and wipes off.
- PVC-free PEVA: Per the listing.
- Magnets and metal grommets: Three magnets, 12 rustproof grommets.
Cons:
- Plain look: Clear plastic adds little decor on its own.
- Magnets need a metal tub: They hold best on cast iron or steel.
Who Should Buy This
Great match for: anyone who needs a low-cost waterproof barrier, alone or behind a fabric curtain. Think twice if: you want a soft, decorative curtain by itself.
How to Choose Between a Fabric and a Plastic Shower Curtain
Water protection
Plastic liners such as PEVA keep water in the tub. Cotton fabric curtains look softer but are usually not waterproof, so most bathrooms use both: a fabric curtain outside and a liner inside.
Plastic type and smell
PVC shower curtains can carry a strong plastic smell from off-gassing, and many PVC formulas include phthalates. PEVA, like the Mrs Awesome liner, is a PVC-free alternative. The EPA’s indoor air quality guidelines are a useful reference for anyone sensitive to indoor air in a small, closed bathroom.
Cleaning and mildew
A fabric curtain can be machine washed, as the Madison Park listing states. A PEVA liner wipes clean with a damp cloth; replace it when mildew sets into the hem. Spreading both out after a shower helps them dry.
Hardware
Choose rust-resistant metal grommets and hooks, and weighted hems or magnets to keep a liner from billowing. The Amazon Basics shower curtain review covers a budget fabric option, Simplehuman’s shower curtain review looks at heavy-duty alternatives, and the Utopia Towels shower curtain review goes deeper on fabric outer curtains.
Our Final Recommendation
For most bathrooms, the Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner is the practical pick: PVC-free PEVA, three magnets at the hem and 12 rustproof grommets. For the look of the room, the Madison Park Arlo Cotton Waffle Shower Curtain adds a machine-washable, OEKO-TEX certified cotton layer outside the liner. Together they give a soft fabric look with a waterproof barrier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a fabric or plastic shower curtain better?
Plastic keeps water in and wipes clean; fabric looks softer and can be machine washed. Most bathrooms use a fabric curtain outside with a plastic liner inside.
Do fabric shower curtains need a liner?
Usually yes. Cotton curtains such as the Madison Park Arlo are not listed as waterproof, so a liner keeps water off the fabric and the floor.
Is PEVA safer than PVC?
PEVA is chlorine-free and PVC-free, and is commonly chosen to avoid the strong smell and phthalates associated with some PVC curtains.
How do I stop a shower liner from blowing in?
Use a liner with weighted hems or magnets. The Mrs Awesome liner has three encased magnets that hold to cast iron or steel tubs.
How often should I wash a fabric shower curtain?
Wash it whenever it looks or smells musty, often every few weeks in a busy bathroom, following the care label. The Madison Park Arlo is listed as machine washable.
